000 02944cam a22003857 4500
001 w26161
003 NBER
005 20211020104045.0
006 m o d
007 cr cnu||||||||
008 210910s2019 mau fo 000 0 eng d
100 1 _aCarrera, Mariana.
245 1 0 _aWho Chooses Commitment? Evidence and Welfare Implications /
_cMariana Carrera, Heather Royer, Mark Stehr, Justin Sydnor, Dmitry Taubinsky.
260 _aCambridge, Mass.
_bNational Bureau of Economic Research
_c2019.
300 _a1 online resource:
_billustrations (black and white);
490 1 _aNBER working paper series
_vno. w26161
500 _aAugust 2019.
520 3 _aThis paper investigates whether offers of commitment contracts, in the form of self-imposed choice-set restrictions and penalties with no financial upside, are well-targeted tools for addressing self-control problems. In an experiment on gym attendance (N= 1;248), we examine take-up of commitment contracts, and also introduce a separate elicitation task to identify actual and perceived time inconsistency. There is high take-up of commitment contracts for greater gym attendance, resulting in significant increases in exercise. However, this is take-up is influenced both by noisy valuation and incorrect beliefs about one's time inconsistency. Approximately half of the people who take up commitment contracts for higher gym attendance also take up commitment contracts for lower gym attendance. There is little association between commitment contract take-up and reduced-form and structural estimates of actual or perceived time inconsistency. A novel information treatment providing an exogenous shock to awareness of time inconsistency reduces demand for commitment contracts. Structural estimates of a model of quasi-hyperbolic discounting and gym attendance imply that offering our commitment contracts lowers consumer surplus, and is less socially efficient than utilizing linear exercise subsidies that achieve the same average change in behavior.
530 _aHardcopy version available to institutional subscribers
538 _aSystem requirements: Adobe [Acrobat] Reader required for PDF files.
538 _aMode of access: World Wide Web.
588 0 _aPrint version record
690 7 _aC9 - Design of Experiments
_2Journal of Economic Literature class.
690 7 _aD9 - Micro-Based Behavioral Economics
_2Journal of Economic Literature class.
690 7 _aI12 - Health Behavior
_2Journal of Economic Literature class.
700 1 _aRoyer, Heather.
700 1 _aStehr, Mark.
700 1 _aSydnor, Justin.
700 1 _aTaubinsky, Dmitry.
710 2 _aNational Bureau of Economic Research.
830 0 _aWorking Paper Series (National Bureau of Economic Research)
_vno. w26161.
856 4 0 _uhttps://www.nber.org/papers/w26161
856 _yAcceso en lĂ­nea al DOI
_uhttp://dx.doi.org/10.3386/w26161
942 _2ddc
_cW-PAPER
999 _c321961
_d280523